Home | Entertainment | The Rise of True Crime in Entertainment
True crime has evolved from a niche genre to a mainstream cultural phenomenon, dominating books, podcasts, documentaries, and scripted television series. Whether it's a real-life murder mystery, a high-profile trial, or a chilling criminal investigation, the fascination with true crime seems to know no bounds. But what is it about these stories that has captured the collective imagination of audiences worldwide? From Serial to Making a Murderer, the rise of true crime in entertainment is not just a trend—it’s a cultural shift.
In this article, we’ll explore the reasons behind the genre's explosive popularity, how it’s impacted entertainment, and the ethical debates surrounding the portrayal of real-life tragedies.
1. The Psychology Behind the Fascination with True Crime
At its core, true crime taps into a primal curiosity that all humans share—the desire to understand the darker aspects of human nature. Why do people commit crimes? What drives someone to take another life or break the law in unimaginable ways? True crime stories, with their compelling real-life narratives, offer a way to explore these questions in an engaging and often unsettling way.
Psychologists argue that people are drawn to these stories because they provide a sense of psychological distance. Audiences can experience the thrill of danger and suspense without being personally involved or at risk. True crime also engages a need for justice. When we see a criminal brought to justice, it restores a sense of order and fairness, which can be comforting in a world that often feels unpredictable.
Moreover, the intricacy of real-life mysteries adds another layer of intrigue. Unlike fictional crime dramas, true crime often involves real people, real emotions, and real consequences. There’s an inherent fascination with trying to understand the "why" behind a crime, especially when the motives are unclear or when the criminal acts against societal norms in shocking ways.
2. The Evolution of True Crime Entertainment
While true crime has been a part of the entertainment landscape for centuries, its recent surge can be traced back to a few pivotal moments and trends.
The Podcast Revolution: Serial and the Rise of Audio Storytelling
In 2014, the release of Serial, a podcast that revisited the 1999 murder case of Hae Min Lee and the conviction of Adnan Syed, was a game-changer for the genre. The podcast captivated millions, breaking download records and sparking a public conversation about the justice system, the flaws in criminal investigations, and the notion of "true crime storytelling."
Serial proved that the format of podcasting—characterized by its intimacy and in-depth exploration—was an ideal medium for true crime content. What made Serial stand out was its investigative approach and the ability to allow listeners to form their own conclusions as they followed the case. This type of storytelling encouraged audience participation, prompting discussions online, social media movements, and even the reopening of cases.
Other podcasts followed in Serial's wake, such as My Favorite Murder, Criminal, and The Murder of Mary Phagan, each adding new layers to the genre with humor, perspective, or investigative journalism.
Documentaries and Netflix: A True Crime Explosion
Streaming platforms like Netflix and Hulu have been central to the rise of true crime in entertainment. Shows like Making a Murderer (2015), which follows the story of Steven Avery, a man who was wrongfully convicted of a crime, only to be accused of another crime years later, and The Keepers (2017), about the unsolved murder of a nun and the abuse scandal it uncovers, have become global sensations. These documentaries not only tell gripping real-life stories but also take a critical look at the justice system, investigative techniques, and societal issues, making them relevant to both true crime aficionados and general viewers.
Netflix, in particular, has invested heavily in the genre. Since Making a Murderer became a breakout hit, the platform has released a string of true crime documentaries, such as The Ted Bundy Tapes (2019), Conversations with a Killer: The John Wayne Gacy Tapes (2022), and The Tinder Swindler (2022), each offering a different lens through which to view the real-life drama, danger, and complexity of crime.
This shift to streaming allowed true crime to reach a wider audience than ever before, making it easy for people to binge-watch entire seasons and immerse themselves in a case over days or weeks. For a global audience, true crime documentaries provide a shared viewing experience that fosters conversation and engagement.
3. True Crime in Scripted Television
The success of true crime documentaries has also influenced scripted television. Shows like The People v. O.J. Simpson: American Crime Story (2016), Mindhunter (2017-2019), and When They See Us (2019) have blurred the lines between documentary and drama. These series take well-known criminal cases and offer dramatic retellings, often focusing on the investigation, courtroom drama, or the social and psychological impact of the crime.
The popularity of these shows is evident in their critical acclaim and ability to attract major stars. The People v. O.J. Simpson garnered multiple Emmy Awards, and Mindhunter has become a cult favorite, particularly for its portrayal of FBI agents trying to understand the psychology of serial killers.
By dramatizing real events, scripted shows give viewers a more emotional and character-driven narrative. These series often focus not just on the crime itself but on the broader societal implications, offering viewers a chance to reflect on issues of race, class, and justice.
4. The Ethics of True Crime Entertainment
Despite its popularity, the rise of true crime has raised significant ethical concerns. One of the biggest debates centers around the exploitation of real-life victims and their families. True crime entertainment often relies on tragic, violent events for its drama, but there’s a growing sense that these stories can commodify the suffering of those involved.
Critics argue that some productions prioritize entertainment value over the emotional well-being of the people directly affected by the crimes. For instance, documentaries like The Jinx: The Life and Deaths of Robert Durst (2015) and The Staircase (2004, 2018) have been accused of sensationalizing real events for the sake of storytelling, while potentially harming those who have already been traumatized by the events being discussed.
Another ethical dilemma arises when true crime stories are used to generate revenue. In some cases, there are concerns that making a spectacle of tragedy may minimize the human cost, turning a horrific event into a voyeuristic experience for viewers.
The line between respect for victims and the desire for sensationalism can often become blurred, leading some to question whether entertainment companies should take a more responsible approach when handling sensitive material.
5. The Future of True Crime in Entertainment
As the genre continues to evolve, true crime will likely keep finding new ways to captivate audiences. With the rise of AI technology, data analysis, and citizen investigations, the intersection of true crime and digital media will only grow more complex. Interactive formats, virtual reality, and crowdsourced investigations may all become part of the future of true crime entertainment.
There’s also a growing trend toward true crime stories that center on lesser-known cases, with an emphasis on social justice and systemic issues. As audiences demand more diverse narratives, there’s potential for the genre to evolve beyond high-profile cases and include voices from marginalized communities whose stories have often been overlooked.
Conclusion
The rise of true crime in entertainment reflects a deep cultural fascination with crime, justice, and the mysteries of human behavior. Whether in documentaries, podcasts, or scripted series, the genre has transformed the way we consume media, blending real-life intrigue with the emotional and intellectual satisfaction of unraveling complex stories. While the genre’s popularity shows no signs of waning, it’s important to consider the ethical implications of how these real-life tragedies are portrayed and consumed. As true crime continues to evolve, it will undoubtedly keep capturing our attention—but with a growing awareness of the responsibility that comes with telling these stories.